Where to Get the Best Thanksgiving Pies in Toronto This Year (2025)

Let’s talk about the most important part of Thanksgiving dinner: the pie. While the turkey and stuffing are great, everyone knows that dessert is the main event.

But baking from scratch while you are also trying to cook a huge meal can be a lot of work. That is why we have put together a guide to the best bakeries in Toronto for your Thanksgiving pies. Whether you want a classic pumpkin pie or something a little different, these spots will help you finish your holiday meal on a high note.

A Quick Pro-Tip for 2025: Since Thanksgiving pies are in ridiculously high demand, most of these amazing bakeries work on a pre-order basis that opens up in mid-to-late September. While this list features Toronto’s most reliable pie-makers, menus can be seasonal. We highly recommend checking their websites or giving them a call closer to the date to confirm their 2025 menu and get your order in early. Seriously, don’t wait until the week of Thanksgiving – you’ll be left pie-less.

The Ultimate Guide to Toronto’s Best Thanksgiving Pies for 2025

Classic Spots for a Traditional Pie

Wanda’s Pie in the Sky

When a place is named for pie, you know it has to be good. Wanda’s is a Kensington Market staple. They offer a huge variety of pies with flaky crusts and high-quality fillings. Their classic pumpkin and apple are always a hit.

• Location: 287 Augusta Ave, Toronto
• Good to Know: They sell out for Thanksgiving every year. Pre-ordering weeks in advance is highly recommended.
• Website: https://www.wandaspieinthesky.com

Phipps Bakery Cafe

An uptown favorite at Yonge & Eglinton for decades. Phipps makes consistently good pies that taste homemade. Their fruit pies like apple and cherry are solid choices, and their pumpkin pie is great for a traditional Thanksgiving.

• Location: 2155 Yonge St, Toronto, ON M4S 2A9
• Good to Know: Expect a line during the holidays. Pre-ordering is a smart move.
• Website: https://phippsbakerycafe.ca

SanRemo Bakery

This famous Etobicoke bakery is known for its donuts, but their holiday pies are also very popular. Their pumpkin and apple pies are rich and flavorful, making them a great choice for a big family dinner.

• Location: 3700 Royal York Rd, Etobicoke, ON M9L 1A6
• Good to Know: It can get very busy. Ordering ahead is your best bet.
• Website: https://sanremobakery.com

Sweetie Pie’s

This Junction bakery has quickly become a local favorite. They focus on quality ingredients and classic recipes. You can expect great seasonal fruit pies along with pumpkin and pecan for Thanksgiving.

• Location: 2316B Bloor St W, Toronto
• Good to Know: This is a smaller shop, so pre-ordering is the way to go.
• Website: https://www.mysweetiepie.ca

For Something a Little Different

The Grand Order of Divine Sweetness (GOODS)

This place is well-known for its butter tarts, but the pies are just as good. GOODS uses high-quality ingredients, and their crust is exceptional. Their pumpkin pie is very popular. This is a good spot if you want to impress your guests.

• Location: 1111 Queen St E, Toronto
• Good to Know: They sell out fast. Pre-ordering is a must for holidays.
• Website: https://shop.thegoodsweets.com

Roselle Desserts

For a more gourmet pie, check out Roselle Desserts. They specialize in French pastries, and their holiday pies have a refined touch. Expect interesting flavor combinations and great presentation.

• Location: 362 King St E, Toronto
• Good to Know: They make limited quantities, so pre-ordering is essential.
• Website: https://www.roselleto.com

Sweet Flour Bake Shop

While known for cookies, Sweet Flour offers comforting, home-style pies for Thanksgiving. Their apple pie is especially good, often made with a mix of different apple varieties for more flavor.

• Location: 130 Cawthra Ave, Unit 105, Toronto
• Good to Know: Pre-ordering is highly recommended during the holiday rush.
• Website: https://www.sweetflour.ca

Bakerbots Baking

This Bloorcourt spot often puts a creative twist on traditional pie flavors. They are a local favorite for their custom cakes, but their Thanksgiving pies are also a great choice. Keep an eye on their social media for the holiday menu.

• Location: 205 Delaware Ave, Toronto
• Good to Know: It is best to pre-order, especially for specific flavors.
• Website: https://www.bakerbotsbaking.com

More Great Bakeries Around the City

The Rolling Pin Bakeshop

Famous for donuts, but The Rolling Pin also makes great pies. They use quality ingredients and offer classic favorites alongside more creative options. Their pumpkin pie is a popular choice.

• Location: 1970 Avenue Rd, North York
• Good to Know: Definitely pre-order for Thanksgiving to get the pie you want.
• Website: https://therollingpin.ca

Bobbette & Belle

If you want a pie with a clean and polished look, Bobbette & Belle is a great option. They are known for macarons and cakes, but their seasonal pies are always well-made with refined flavors.

• Location: Multiple locations (e.g., 112 Yorkville Ave, Toronto)
• Good to Know: Pre-ordering is essential for holiday pickups.
• Website: https://bobbetteandbelle.com

Summerhill Market

Summerhill Market has a great prepared foods section and a bakery that makes tasty pies. Their apple and pumpkin pies have a homemade style and are a reliable choice when you need a good option without the fuss.

• Location: Multiple locations (e.g., 446 Summerhill Ave, Toronto)
• Good to Know: Check with your local store for their Thanksgiving ordering process.
• Website: https://summerhillmarket.com

Blackbird Baking Co.

Primarily a bread bakery, Blackbird often sells rustic, delicious pies during the holidays. Their focus on quality ingredients means you will get a pie with a hearty flavor and a good crust.

• Location: Multiple locations (e.g., 172 Baldwin St, Toronto)
• Good to Know: Watch their social media for holiday pie announcements.
• Website: https://www.blackbirdbakingco.com

Bake Shoppe

This Queen West spot is known for its fun, retro style. For Thanksgiving, they offer classic pies, often with decorated crusts. Their pumpkin pie is known for its rich and creamy filling.

• Location: 85 Front St E, Toronto
• Good to Know: Pre-ordering is highly recommended to get your pies.
• Website: https://www.bakeshoppeto.com

Bunner’s Bakeshop

This is a go-to spot for anyone who needs vegan and gluten-free options. Bunner’s makes pies that meet dietary restrictions without losing flavor. Their pumpkin pie is a standout and is popular with everyone.

• Location: Multiple locations (e.g., 244 Augusta Ave, Toronto)
• Good to Know: Pre-order well in advance for special dietary needs.
• Website: https://bunners.ca

Demetres

While known for sit-down desserts, Demetres often offers pies for the holidays. They tend to have generous portions that are good for a large gathering. Their pumpkin pie is a rich and satisfying option.

• Location: Multiple locations across Toronto
• Good to Know: Check their website for holiday menu announcements.
• Website: https://demetres.com

Pie Commission

This place is all about pies, so you know they take it seriously. Pie Commission offers a great selection of sweet and savory pies. For Thanksgiving, their classic fruit and pumpkin pies are well-made and balanced.

• Location: 863 Bathurst St, Toronto
• Good to Know: Pre-ordering is essential, especially for full-sized pies.
• Website: https://piecommission.com

There you have it. Your guide to handling the Thanksgiving dessert table without all the stress. Happy Thanksgiving!

Need Help with the Rest of the Meal?

Now that you have dessert figured out, what about the main course? If you would rather skip the cooking altogether, many Toronto restaurants offer full Thanksgiving dinners for takeout. You can get the turkey, stuffing, and all the sides ready to go.

Find a great spot in our guide to the Best Thanksgiving Dinners in Toronto.

More…

• https://www.overheretoronto.com/whats-open-and-closed-in-toronto-on-thanksgiving-weekend
• https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodToronto/comments/pxei5u/where_to_go_for_pumpkin_pie
• https://streetsoftoronto.com/food/where-to-find-the-best-thanksgiving-pies-in-toronto