15 Best Stores for Halloween Costumes in Toronto (2025)

Alright, T.O., the spooky season countdown is officially on, and the pressure is mounting to figure out the costume. Whether you’re aiming for spooky, funny, or something totally out there, finding the right gear is half the battle. If you’re currently scrolling, trying to find the best Halloween stores for costumes in Toronto, stress less; I’ve got the lowdown on where to score everything from full head-to-toe looks to those perfect finishing touches for 2025.

Heads up, costume crew. Store hours, pop-up locations, and stock levels can be as unpredictable as a ghost. It is always a smart move to check official websites or give them a quick call before you head out on your quest.

Best Halloween Stores for Costumes in Toronto

The Big Pop-Up King

Spirit Halloween

Let’s just get the obvious one out of the way. Spirit Halloween descends upon the city every fall, taking over empty storefronts and offering a massive selection of pre-packaged costumes, accessories, and spooky decor. It’s convenient, has tons of options (especially for popular characters), and is a go-to for many.

• Price: $$
• Location: 415 King St W, Toronto (other locations)
• Contact: https://stores.spirithalloween.com/on/toronto/halloween-store-64810.html | 855-704-2669
• Pro Tip: Go early in October for the best selection, especially for popular sizes. Weekday visits are way less chaotic than the weekend madness closer to Halloween.

The Year-Round Costume Experts

Theatrix Costume House

Another professional heavyweight. Theatrix primarily rents out incredibly detailed costumes for film, theatre, and events, but they do have options for individual rentals too. If you need something super specific or historically accurate, they probably have it.

• Price: $$$$
• Location: 162 ½, Kensington Ave N, Hamilton
• Contact: https://theatrixcostumehouse.com  | (416) 977-3113 | rentals@theatrixcostumehouse.com 
• Pro Tip: It’s best to call ahead and book an appointment, especially during the busy Halloween season, as they cater heavily to industry professionals.

The Local Favourites

Thunder Thighs Costumes LTD

This Toronto institution has been dressing up locals for decades. Known for its theatre-quality rentals and wild selection of accessories, it’s a go-to for anyone serious about standing out. If you want a full Victorian gown or a superhero getup, they’ve got you covered — literally.

• Price: $$–$$$
•  Location: 16 Busy St, Toronto
• Contact: https://thunderthighscostumes.com | 416-462-0621 | thunderhighscostumes@gmail.com 
• Pro Tip: Visit early — fittings can get busy as Halloween approaches, and staff are great at helping you mix and match pieces for a unique look.

Party City

When you need a one-stop shop for costumes, wigs, makeup, and party supplies, Party City delivers. They’ve got everything from kids’ princess dresses to adult cosplay-level outfits. Plus, it’s a lifesaver for last-minute planners.

• Price: $$
•  Location: 1225 Finch Ave W, Toronto (other locations)
• Contact: www.partycity.ca/en/store-details/on/toronto-finch-on-party-city-815.html | 416-631-7688
• Pro Tip: Their website often lists which stores have certain costumes in stock.

The Treasure Hunt: Vintage & Thrift Stores

Value Village

Okay, hear me out. For creative, budget-friendly costumes, Value Village is the G.O.A.T. It requires some digging, but you can find amazing vintage pieces, old uniforms, weird accessories, and even brand-new, packaged costumes for way less. It’s perfect for putting together a unique look.

• Price: $
• Location: 18 Edward St Unit #3 & #5, Toronto (other locations)
• Contact: https://stores.savers.com/on/toronto/valuevillage-thrift-store-2180.html | 647-255-1622 
• Pro Tip: Go often in October, as new stuff comes in daily. Hit up locations slightly outside the downtown core for potentially better finds and fewer crowds.

Kensington Market (Various Shops)

Kensington isn’t one store; it’s an entire vibe. Wander through the market and pop into the various vintage shops like Courage My Love, Exile Vintage, or Sub Rosa Vintage. You’ll find incredible retro clothing, unique accessories, and tons of inspiration for putting together a killer costume.

• Price: $-$$$
• Location: Kensington Avenue, Toronto
• Contact: https://kensingtonmarket.to | info@kensingtonmarket.to 
• Good For: Finding authentic vintage pieces to build a unique costume. Perfect for decades-themed looks (70s, 80s, 90s).

Black Market Vintage

Located downstairs on Queen West, Black Market is known for its super cheap vintage finds, especially t-shirts, jeans, and flannel. It’s a goldmine for putting together grunge, punk, or casual retro costumes on a serious budget.

• Price: $
• Location: Upstairs, 347 Queen St W, 2nd floor, Toronto (other locations)
• Contact: https://blackmarkettoronto.com | 416-599-5858 | Info@blackmarkettoronto.com 
• Pro Tip: Be prepared to dig through packed racks. The prices are unbeatable if you have some patience.

Specialty & Unique Finds

BMV Books

While primarily a bookstore, the massive BMV location on Bloor often carries a surprisingly good selection of pop culture t-shirts, costumes, masks, and nerdy accessories around Halloween. It’s worth popping in if you’re in the Annex.

• Price: $$
• Location: 471 Bloor St W, Toronto
• Contact: www.bmvbooks.com  | (416) 967-5757 | bmvbooks@rogers.com 
• Good For: Pop culture costumes, masks, and nerdy apparel. You can browse for books while you’re there.

Hollywood Tickle Trunk

Located in Richmond Hill, but worth mentioning if you’re in the north end of the GTA. This year-round costume shop has a huge selection of both rentals and sales, covering everything from superheroes to historical figures.

• Price: $$-$$$
• Location: 2840 Slough Street, Mississauga
• Contact: www.hollywoodtickletrunk.ca  | (647) 286-5941 
• Good For: A wide variety of themes and high-quality rental options outside the downtown core.

AnimeXtreme

Searching for an anime cosplay store in Toronto? AnimeXtreme is a go-to. While primarily focused on anime/manga merch, they carry cosplay items, wigs, and accessories that are perfect for putting together character looks for Halloween or conventions.

• Price: $$$
• Location: 327 Spadina Ave. Main Floor, Toronto
• Contact: https://animextreme.ca  | 416-979-0399 | store@animextreme.ca 
• Pro Tip: If you’re looking for a specific character’s wig or accessory, this is one of your best bets in the city.

Little Party Shoppe

A Leslieville gem for party supplies that also ramps up its costume and accessory game for Halloween. It’s a great local spot to find fun items for kids’ costumes and essential accessories for adults.

• Price: $$
• Location: 2566 Yonge St., Toronto
• Contact: www.littlepartyshoppe.ca | 416-487-7855
• Good For: Last-minute accessories and kids’ costume pieces in the East End.

Candy’s Costume Shop

Another solid year-round costume shop offering both rentals and sales. Candy’s has a wide range of themes and is known for its helpful staff who can assist you in finding or putting together the perfect look.

• Price: $$-$$$
• Location: 685 Mt Pleasant Rd, Toronto
• Contact: https://www.candyscostumeshop.com | 416-487-5794 | dressup@candyscostumeshop.com 
• Pro Tip: They have a great selection of mascot costumes if you’re looking for something really attention-grabbing.

Reflections Vintage, Antiques & Theatrical Costumes

Part vintage store, part theatrical supply, Reflections is a hidden treasure trove. You can find authentic vintage clothing perfect for period costumes, alongside unique accessories and props. It’s a great spot for the creative costume builder.

• Price: $$-$$$
• Location: 839 Gerrard Street E, West Grey, ON
• Contact: www.reflectionsvintage.com  | (416) 944-0333 
• Good For: Finding authentic vintage pieces and unique accessories you won’t see anywhere else.

Midoco Art & Office Supplies

Wait, an art store? Yes. Midoco has an amazing selection of craft supplies, face paint, masks, feathers, glitter, and everything else you might need for DIY costume elements or killer Halloween makeup.

• Price: $$
• Location: 555 Bloor St W, Toronto (other locations)
• Contact: https://midoco.ca  | (416) 588-7718
• Pro Tip: Their selection of professional face and body paint is top-notch for creating intricate makeup looks.

Amazon.ca / Online Retailers

Let’s be real, sometimes convenience wins. Online retailers offer an almost infinite selection delivered to your door. Just be sure to order well in advance to account for shipping times, especially with potential delays around the holidays.

• Price: $-$$$$
• Location: Online
• Contact: www.amazon.ca  
• Pro Tip: Read the reviews carefully, especially regarding sizing and quality. What looks great in the photo might be disappointing IRL.

Want something less spooky and more family-friendly?

If you’re planning Halloween fun that’s big on treats and light on scares, don’t miss my guide to Top Family-Friendly Halloween Events in Toronto That Won’t Scare the Kids. It’s packed with pumpkin patches, themed parades, and not-so-spooky adventures perfect for little ghosts and goblins.

More…

• https://www.destinationtoronto.com/leisure-blog/post/costumes-cosplay-events-toronto
• https://www.yelp.ca/search?find_desc=Costume+Stores&find_loc=Toronto%2C+ON
• https://viewthevibe.com/heres-where-to-shop-for-halloween-costumes-in-toronto