For Sale: Historic Toronto Hotel Near Mimico for Nearly $10 Million

For over 130 years, the building at 1 Blue Goose Street in Etobicoke has been a cornerstone of the community. Most well-known as the Blue Goose Tavern, this historic Toronto hotel has not only survived fire and renovation but has also remained a symbolic gathering spot for locals and travelers alike. Now, this partially-renovated icon is for sale under a power of sale listing — a trend becoming all too common in the current Toronto real estate landscape. Consequently, with a price tag of almost $10 million, the property promises immense potential for the right buyer.

Historic Etobicoke Venue for Sale After Years of Transformation

The Iconic Legacy of the Blue Goose Tavern

Originally opened in 1892 as the Windsor Hotel, this heritage structure began its story welcoming visitors and locals across from the Mimico GO Station. After suffering a destructive fire in 1905, it was rebuilt in 1909 and renamed the Windsor Public House. Locals continued to cherish it. By 1971, it had earned the affectionate nickname “Blue Goose Tavern,” referencing a steam engine with a blue tint that often stopped nearby.

• Year Built: 1892 (rebuilt in 1909)
• Notable Ownership: The Chemij family (since 1958)
• Current Status: Designated on Toronto’s Heritage Register

• Background on historical origins of the Blue Goose Tavern: https://www.toronto.com/life/blue-goose-tavern-to-be-designated-under-citys-heritage-register/article_536acb42-d9fc-56fd-96d8-92e0b7a73b28.html
• History of the Chemij family taking over the Blue Goose Tavern: https://unfcanada.ca/the-chemij-family-passes-the-keys-to-the-blue-goose-tavern/
• City of Toronto agenda where 1 Blue Goose Street was deemed eligible for heritage designation: https://secure.toronto.ca/council/agenda-item.do?item=2017.PB22.6

Modern Upgrades with Historic Charm

Fast forward to 2018: Allegra Homes took over the property with a vision to breathe life into it as “The New Goose,” a mixed-use hub. The renovation aimed to transform the building into a vibrant space, complete with ground-floor commercial units perfect for a microbrewery or restaurant. Above, 18 newly-built rental apartments — primarily bachelor and one-bedroom layouts — were added, appealing to those seeking modern living in a heritage setting. Furthermore, the integration of history and innovation adds to its appeal.

• Commercial Space Size: 5,000 sq. ft. on ground and lower levels
• Residential Units: 18 rental apartments
• Completion Status: Estimated 90% complete

• News on Allegra Homes’ redevelopment plans for the Blue Goose Tavern: https://www.toronto.com/news/new-owners-of-mimicos-blue-goose-tavern-plan-microbrewery-townhomes/article_166f4044-0beb-5b3e-be35-91c682c94d45.html
• Official site for redevelopment project ‘The New Goose’: https://thenewgoose.ca
• Real estate listing for 1 Blue Goose Street showing project is 90% complete: https://www.realtor.ca/real-estate/28669139/1-blue-goose-street-toronto-mimico-mimico
• Website for renting brand-new apartments at The New Goose: https://rentatnewgoose.ca

Development Potential Beyond the Main Structure

In addition to the tavern redevelopment, the listing includes adjacent land approved for further residential use. Plans for 12 townhomes have already been approved for the rear lot, although construction has not yet commenced. Moreover, early discussions have hinted at the site’s potential for a mid-rise condominium development. This offers even more appeal to investors and developers eyeing Toronto’s competitive housing market.

• Total Lot Size: 25,000 sq. ft.
• Townhome Approvals: 12 units
• Mid-Rise Potential: Preliminary planning stage

• Details on approved 12 townhomes at the rear lot of the Blue Goose site: https://strata.ca/toronto/1-blue-goose-street-west-six-urban-towns
• Project page for the West Six Towns development connected to the Blue Goose site: https://www.condoshq.com/toronto-townhomes/the-west-six-towns

A Rare Opportunity in the Toronto Market

Now listed at $9,620,000 and sold “as-is, where-is,” this historic Toronto hotel offers a compelling opportunity for someone with the vision and resources to complete the transformation. Given its prime location, rich history, and strong architectural bones, this is more than just a real estate listing — it’s a chance to carry forward a landmark’s legacy. In short, it’s an investment that blends the past with future possibilities.

• Power of sale signal in Toronto’s housing market: https://www.blogto.com/real-estate-toronto/2025/06/another-sign-toronto-housing-market-turmoil

Whether restored to its former tavern glory, expanded into a residential complex, or reimagined as a commercial anchor in Mimico, the historic Toronto hotel known as the Blue Goose Tavern is ready for its next chapter. Therefore, real estate enthusiasts looking for both charm and challenge may find this project especially enticing.

More…

• https://unfcanada.ca/the-chemij-family-passes-the-keys-to-the-blue-goose-tavern/
• https://www.toronto.com/news/councillors-approve-blue-goose-redevelopment-heritage-designation/article_15b5c761-2efb-56b5-87b4-8985e7f4899a.html
• https://www.facebook.com/groups/1579752435674910/posts/3887717904878340/
• https://www.overheretoronto.com/cabbagetown-art-craft-show/