10 Places for the Best Thanksgiving Pies in Toronto in 2026
Thanksgiving dessert gets easier once the pie order is handled. Toronto bakeries are already posting pumpkin, apple, pecan and other seasonal pies for the October long weekend, and several have firm preorder cutoffs before Thanksgiving Monday.
This list focuses on Toronto shops with current pie menus or 2026 Thanksgiving information available now. It covers traditional pumpkin, fruit pies, nut pies and options for vegan or gluten-free guests, with pricing and ordering notes listed under each bakery.
Canadian Thanksgiving falls on Monday, October 12, 2026. Prices and availability below were checked September 23, 2026, but holiday inventory can change quickly, so use the linked bakery page to confirm stock and pickup timing before heading out.
Wanda’s Pie in the Sky
Wanda’s Pie in the Sky is a strong fit for a Thanksgiving table when people want different kinds of pie rather than one flavour for everyone. The Kensington Market bakery carries fruit, cream, custard and nut pies, so an order can cover apple for the traditional crowd and something richer for dessert-first guests.
For 2026, the timing is the part to note. Thanksgiving preorders close Tuesday, October 6 at 4 p.m. The bakery also plans walk-in stock over Thanksgiving weekend, but preordering gives you more control over size and flavour. Current pricing runs from smaller pies at about $15 to larger formats near $58, with 9-inch fruit and apple pies listed at $33.
- Type of Cuisine: Bakery and cafe; fruit, cream, custard and nut pies
- Location(s): 287 Augusta Avenue, Kensington Market
- Price Range: $15-$58 CAD depending on size and pie family; 9-inch fruit and apple pies are $33
- Menu Highlights: Apple, sour cherry and other fruit pies; cream pies; pecan; chocolate pecan; seasonal pumpkin
- Thanksgiving Special: Thanksgiving preorders close October 6 at 4 p.m.; walk-in pies are planned for Thanksgiving weekend
- Website: Wanda’s Pie in the Sky
- Instagram: Wanda’s Pie in the Sky | Reviews: 4.3/5 from about 2,015 Google reviews at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://wandaspieinthesky.com/order/
Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop
Phipps is a practical choice for households sticking with the pie flavours people already expect at Thanksgiving. The Eglinton West bakery lists traditional apple, crumble-topped fruit pies, pecan, chocolate pecan, toasted lemon meringue, key lime and cranberry pecan among its current options.
Full-size pies generally land in the upper-$20s to mid-$30s, depending on the flavour. The holiday-hours page currently shows the bakery open Saturday, October 10 and closed Sunday, October 11, so a Saturday pickup makes more sense than leaving dessert until the day before Thanksgiving.
- Type of Cuisine: Bakery and cafe; fruit pies, pecan pies, tarts and cakes
- Location(s): 420 Eglinton Avenue West
- Price Range: About $26.99-$36.99 CAD for current full-size pies; size and flavour affect price
- Menu Highlights: Traditional apple, crumble-topped fruit pies, pecan, chocolate pecan, toasted lemon meringue, key lime, cranberry pecan
- Thanksgiving Special: Current holiday schedule shows Saturday, October 10 open and Sunday, October 11 closed; plan pickup earlier
- Website: Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop
- Instagram: Phipps Bakery & Dessert Shop | Reviews: 4.5/5 from about 490 Google reviews at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://phippsbakerycafe.ca/collections/pies-1
SanRemo Bakery
SanRemo makes sense when the Thanksgiving bakery run needs to cover more than pie. The Etobicoke shop combines an Italian bakery, cafe, grocery counter and prepared-food selection, which is useful if bread, pastries or a few extra items are still missing from the meal plan.
Its regular pie menu includes apple, blueberry, cherry, lemon, lemon meringue and coconut cream. Whole-pie pricing is not posted on the current site, so this is one to confirm by phone before placing the order. Seasonal items use a separate ordering flow, and the bakery directs customers to call for pies and pastries.
- Type of Cuisine: Italian bakery, cafe, grocery and hot table
- Location(s): 374 Royal York Road, Etobicoke
- Price Range: Whole-pie pricing is not currently posted online; call for the latest price
- Menu Highlights: Apple, blueberry, cherry, lemon, lemon meringue and coconut cream pies
- Thanksgiving Special: Seasonal items use a separate ordering flow; confirm pie availability and price by phone
- Website: SanRemo Bakery
- Instagram: SanRemo Bakery | Reviews: 4.6/5 from about 6,098 Google reviews at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://sanremobakery.com/cakes/
The Rolling Pin
The Rolling Pin has one of the broader Thanksgiving-specific lineups on this list. Alongside traditional pumpkin, the current menu moves into pumpkin dulce de leche meringue, chocolate pumpkin mud, Biscoff pumpkin cheesecake, apple cranberry crumble and chocolate pecan.
Most of the Thanksgiving pie lineup sits around $35 to $40. Traditional pumpkin is listed at $35, while the Biscoff pumpkin cheesecake is $40. This is a good stop when the table already has the usual apple pie covered and you want a second dessert with a different flavour profile.
- Type of Cuisine: Dessert bakery; pies, cakes, doughnuts and seasonal sweets
- Location(s): 1970 Avenue Road, North York
- Price Range: About $35-$40 CAD for the current Thanksgiving lineup; some other pies reach $42
- Menu Highlights: Traditional pumpkin, pumpkin dulce de leche meringue, chocolate pumpkin mud, Biscoff pumpkin cheesecake, apple cranberry crumble, chocolate pecan
- Thanksgiving Special: The current Thanksgiving collection is live online; advance ordering is recommended
- Website: The Rolling Pin
- Instagram: The Rolling Pin | Reviews: 4.3/5 from about 773 Google reviews at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://therollingpin.ca/products/traditional-pumpkin-pie
Bobbette & Belle Artisanal Pastries
Bobbette & Belle keeps its Thanksgiving pie choices fairly focused, which can make ordering easier. The current pumpkin pie is $38, and the bakery also lists individual pumpkin tarts plus bundles that pair pumpkin with either blueberry crumble or apple crumble.
The two-pie bundles are $80, making them useful for a larger table where one pie is not likely to stretch far enough. There are locations on Queen Street East and Yonge Street, so pickup can be planned around whichever part of the city is easier that weekend.
- Type of Cuisine: Pastry shop and bakery; pies, cakes, macarons and seasonal desserts
- Location(s): 1121 Queen Street East and 3347 Yonge Street
- Price Range: $38 CAD for pumpkin pie; $80 CAD for two-pie Thanksgiving bundles
- Menu Highlights: Pumpkin pie, pumpkin tarts, pumpkin with blueberry crumble bundle, pumpkin with apple crumble bundle, pumpkin spice cake
- Thanksgiving Special: Current Thanksgiving two-pie bundles are $80 and online holiday ordering is available
- Website: Bobbette & Belle Artisanal Pastries
- Instagram: Bobbette & Belle Artisanal Pastries | Reviews: 4.3/5 from about 975 Google reviews for the Queen East location at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://bobbetteandbelle.com/product-category/cakes-pies-tortes-toronto/
Bunner’s Bakeshop
Bunner’s gives vegan and gluten-free guests a clear Thanksgiving option without turning dessert into a separate last-minute search. Its 9-inch deep-dish pumpkin pie is listed at $29.95, while the apple butterscotch crumble pie is $34.95.
The deadline matters here. Advance Thanksgiving orders close Wednesday, October 7 at noon, with delivery and store pickup available through October 11. After the cutoff, the bakery says walk-in items are available while stock lasts, so preordering is the safer route if dietary needs are part of the guest list.
- Type of Cuisine: Vegan and gluten-free bakery
- Location(s): 244 Augusta Avenue, Kensington Market
- Price Range: $29.95-$34.95 CAD for the main Thanksgiving pies
- Menu Highlights: Deep-dish pumpkin pie, apple butterscotch crumble pie, Thanksgiving Bakery Bundle and other fall items
- Thanksgiving Special: Advance Thanksgiving orders close October 7 at noon; pickup and delivery continue through October 11
- Website: Bunner’s Bakeshop
- Instagram: Bunner’s Bakeshop | Reviews: 4.4/5 from about 1,066 Google reviews at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://bunners.ca/pages/thanksgiving
Little Pebbles
Little Pebbles is the option to check when pumpkin is not the priority. The Japanese-influenced pastry shop currently lists key lime, salted caramel pecan and pistachio raspberry pies for Thanksgiving, giving the dessert table a sharper citrus option or a richer nut-based choice.
Current prices run from $37 for key lime to $47 for pistachio raspberry, with salted caramel pecan at $42. Some pie pages request 12 to 24 hours of notice, so this is not the shop to leave until the pickup day. The main cafe is on Baldwin Street, with additional Little Pebbles concepts elsewhere downtown.
- Type of Cuisine: Japanese-influenced cafe and pastry shop using French pastry techniques
- Location(s): Main cafe at 160 Baldwin Street; additional concepts on College Street and Augusta Avenue
- Price Range: $37-$47 CAD for current Thanksgiving-special pies
- Menu Highlights: Key lime, salted caramel pecan and pistachio raspberry pies
- Thanksgiving Special: Current pie pages are marked for Thanksgiving; some ask for 12-24 hours of advance notice
- Website: Little Pebbles
- Instagram: Little Pebbles | Reviews: 4.2/5 from about 1,305 Google reviews for the Baldwin location at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://little-pebbles.com/shop
Mabel’s Bakery
Mabel’s is a solid fruit-pie stop for anyone who already has pumpkin covered. The current online collection includes apple, Dutch apple cranberry, sour cherry and wild blueberry, with prices ranging from $12.99 to $29.99 depending on the pie and format.
The bakery has several Toronto locations, including Roncesvalles, Queen West, St. Clair West, The Junction and College Street. A 2026 pumpkin pie was not shown in the online pie collection when checked, so anyone set on pumpkin should call before making the trip. For apple or cranberry, the current menu gives you several routes.
- Type of Cuisine: Neighbourhood bakery; breads, prepared foods, baked goods and fruit pies
- Location(s): Roncesvalles, Queen West, St. Clair West, The Junction, College Street and Samor Road mini store
- Price Range: $12.99-$29.99 CAD across the current online pie collection
- Menu Highlights: Apple, Dutch apple cranberry, sour cherry and wild blueberry pies
- Thanksgiving Special: No 2026 pumpkin pie was shown in the online collection when checked; call about any added seasonal items
- Website: Mabel’s Bakery
- Instagram: Mabel’s Bakery | Reviews: 4.1/5 from about 396 Google reviews for the Roncesvalles location at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://mabelsbakery.ca/collections/pies
Montmartre Bakery
Montmartre Bakery is the budget-friendly pumpkin option in this group based on the posted 2026 price. The Scarborough bakery says its seasonal pumpkin pie starts Friday, October 2 and is priced at $14.75 each.
The bakery’s online order form is currently unavailable, so customers are asked to place orders by phone. That extra step is worth noting if you normally prefer online checkout. Montmartre also carries breads and pastries, making it easy to add breakfast or dinner-table items to the same pickup.
- Type of Cuisine: Family-run artisan bakery; breads, pastries and seasonal pies
- Location(s): 105 Midwest Road, Scarborough
- Price Range: $14.75 CAD for the posted 2026 seasonal pumpkin pie
- Menu Highlights: Seasonal pumpkin pie plus breads, pastries and other baked goods
- Thanksgiving Special: Pumpkin pie starts October 2, 2026 at $14.75; orders are currently handled by phone
- Website: Montmartre Bakery
- Instagram: No verified official account found during research | Reviews: 4.7/5 from about 893 Google reviews at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://montmartrebakery.com/
Tre Mari Bakery
Tre Mari is useful when dessert is part of a larger Thanksgiving food order. The St. Clair West bakery and grocery has a current Thanksgiving catering collection with pasta, mains, sides and sweets, while its pumpkin pie listing is priced at $14.95.
Online stock can change, and the pumpkin pie page may show sold out depending on when you check. Confirm availability before building the rest of the order around it. For hosts who still need several parts of dinner, Tre Mari can reduce the number of separate pickup stops.
- Type of Cuisine: Italian bakery, grocery, deli and prepared-food counter
- Location(s): 1311 St. Clair Avenue West
- Price Range: $14.95 CAD for the pumpkin pie listing; online stock can change
- Menu Highlights: Pumpkin pie, pecan items and a Thanksgiving catering menu with pasta, mains, sides and desserts
- Thanksgiving Special: Current Thanksgiving catering collection is live; confirm pumpkin pie stock before ordering
- Website: Tre Mari Bakery
- Instagram: Tre Mari Bakery | Reviews: 4.6/5 from about 2,489 Google reviews at time of research Google Maps
Current menu / seasonal source: https://www.tremari.ca/products/pumpkin-pie
Order the Pie Before the Long Weekend
The biggest difference between these bakeries is not just flavour; it is also timing. For example, Wanda’s and Bunner’s publish early preorder cutoffs, while Montmartre starts offering its pumpkin pie on October 2. Meanwhile, several other shops depend on changing online stock or phone orders.
First, use the table to choose the right pie. Pumpkin is the classic Thanksgiving option, while apple or cranberry works well for fruit pie fans. For a richer dessert, consider pecan. However, if you need vegan and gluten-free options, Bunner’s is a strong choice. After choosing your pie, confirm the pickup date before placing the rest of your food order.
For a Monday, October 12 dinner, try to place your order during the first week of October. This gives you more flexibility with bakery cutoffs and helps you avoid sold-out items. Finally, check the bakery’s holiday hours again before leaving home, especially if you plan to pick up your order on Sunday.
You Might Also Like…
